23 hotels the community recommends · Updated November 2026
These are the 23 hotels in New York that members of Lametaylim (קהילת למטיילים), a community of 470,000+ Israeli travellers, recommend to each other. Each one is a hotel members sent to someone who asked where to stay in New York.
Considered the best hotel in the city by many travellers. Excellent location on a quiet corner, just minutes from all the action and noise. Highly recommended hotel.
4-star hotel on 50th Street, between Times Square and Rockefeller Center, about 100 metres from 50 St station. Rated 8.9 on Booking, location score 9.7 and no resort fees. Modern, carefully designed, perfect for couples.
4-star hotel on 41st Street, about 170 metres from Times Square and close to Bryant Park. Rated 9.0 on Booking. No resort fees. The rooms are relatively compact (~21-25 sq m in most categories). Perfect for couples.
La Quinta is a famous hotel chain in the United States, and it has several locations in New York too. The La Quinta Times Square hotel is only a 10-minute walk from the famous square.
3-star hotel in Murray Hill, about 400 metres from Grand Central, rated 8.5 from 9,000+ reviews. The rooms are very small (some about 5-13 sq m) with a private shower in every room, not shared. Facility fee of about $30 per night (Wi‑Fi, gym, morning coffee). Perfect for solo travellers/couples on a budget who are happy with a compact room.
Hotel in Midtown, about 200 metres from Macy's and about 600 metres from the Empire State Building. Rooftop bar with a view. Compact rooms (about 14-20 sq m). Destination fee of about $40 per night (including food credit/Wi‑Fi, depending on the hotel's policy). Suitable for couples who like a young atmosphere and don't mind a small room.
Historic 4-star Art Deco hotel on 47th Street in the heart of the Theatre District (since 1930). Location score 9.5. Facility fee of about $42 per night (light breakfast for 2, Wi‑Fi, gym). Perfect for Broadway fans who budget for the fee in advance.
A modern hotel full of art, with designed rooms and a rooftop with a stunning view of the city. The hotel is in the Lower East Side, right next to the SoHo neighbourhood.
An excellent hotel in the SoHo neighbourhood, near plenty of restaurants, cafés and shopping. Good price for New York, with clean, spacious rooms and excellent hotel rules.
Designed 4-star hotel on Hudson Street, between SoHo, Tribeca and the West Village, about 260 metres from Canal St station. Rooftop bar with a panoramic view of the city and a location score of 9.1 on Booking. Perfect for couples.
3-star hotel on 37th Street, between Fifth and Sixth Avenue, with breakfast included and no resort fees. Rated 8.5 on Booking with a location score of 9.5. Perfect for anyone who wants excellent value in the heart of Manhattan.
Located in the Upper West, in the northern part of Manhattan. A good hotel with a variety of rooms, also suitable for families. There is a metro station a 4-minute walk away, from which you can reach Times Square in 5-10 minutes. A safe and pleasant area.
5-star hotel on the corner of Fifth Avenue and Central Park South, ranked fourth in the city in the Condé Nast Traveler 2026 readers' ranking and with a location score of 9.8 on Booking. Perfect for a luxury holiday in New York.
Apartment hotel on 49th Street, about 120 metres from 49 St station and close to Rockefeller Center, with a location score of 9.8 on Booking. Guests mention a kitchen in the apartment, and a free cot up to age 3. Perfect for families.
Hotel in the heart of Williamsburg in Brooklyn, one train stop from the East Village, with a rooftop pool, huge windows and private balconies in many of the rooms. Location score of 9.2 on Booking, surrounded by restaurants and shopping. Perfect for couples.
Hostel on the Upper West Side, about 180 metres from 103 St station, rated 8.7 from over 15,000 reviews on Booking and 8.8 for value. A bed in a shared room, perfect for backpackers and solo travellers.
A designed boutique hotel full of art in SoHo, on Grand Street. On the 18th-floor roof there is the JIMMY bar with a view of the city and an outdoor pool that is open in summer.
Hotel in the heart of SoHo (downtown Manhattan), not in Times Square and not in Midtown. Large rooms and views from the higher floors, a pool. Suitable for anyone who wants the SoHo neighbourhood and is willing to take a longer ride/walk to the Midtown attractions.
A few minutes' walk from Times Square, among the Broadway theatres, with a large terrace on the lobby floor. Guests mention large rooms for New York and friendly staff, but a long wait for the lifts.
4-star hotel on 47th Street, about 250 metres from 49 St station, rated 8.9 (~8,800 reviews). Small standard rooms (~18 sq m). Resort fee of about $34 per night (gym/business centre). A good choice for anyone who wants a location near Times Square and accepts a compact room + a fee.
Every studio has a private kitchen with a dishwasher, and breakfast is included in the price. 3-star hotel in Midtown, about 300 metres from 34 St–Penn station, rated 8.6 on Booking and with no resort fees. Perfect for families who like to cook and save.
4-star hotel on Broadway in NoMad, about 100 metres from the subway station on 28th Street. Rated 9.3 on Booking, location score 9.8 and not a single review under 7 in the last 60. A safe choice for almost any trip to New York.
3-star hotel in Midtown, on 42nd Street, rated 8.6 from over 16,000 reviews on Booking and with a location score of 9.5. One of the best-value private rooms on the list, perfect for anyone who wants to save on accommodation and spend their time out in the city.
The Booking.com links are affiliate links: the price is the same for you, and a small commission helps us run the community.
Have a question this list doesn't answer? Ask in the community's WhatsApp group for New York: people who live there and travellers who are there right now. The group is in Hebrew.
Join the WhatsApp group · About the group
Already booked?Track the price and get an email if it drops.
Questions travellers ask
What is the best-value hotel in New York for Israelis?
The best-value hotel in New York is Pod 39, which is located in central Manhattan and offers functional rooms at a relatively good price for the area, from ₪800 per night. The rooms are small but cleverly designed, and the location is excellent, close to the metro. Another excellent option is Radio City Apartments, which offers furnished apartments a minute from Times Square, from ₪800 per night, with the option to cook and save on meals. Members of the Lametaylim community recommend booking at least three months in advance to get good prices, and checking prices for Sunday to Wednesday, which are significantly cheaper.
Which area of New York is best to stay in, and what are the differences?
The most recommended area for Israeli tourists is Midtown Manhattan, close to Times Square and Central Park. Radio City Apartments and Pod 39 are in this area and offer excellent access. SoHo (lower Manhattan) offers a cool atmosphere with boutiques and galleries: Modernhaus SoHo and Arlo SoHo are located there, at ₪800-₪1,500 per night. Williamsburg in Brooklyn suits anyone who wants a young, local atmosphere, with The Williamsburg Hotel. Members of the Lametaylim community recommend Midtown for first-time visitors, and SoHo or Brooklyn for returning ones.
How much does a hotel in New York cost, and where are there kosher restaurants?
New York is an expensive city and hotel prices reflect that. 4-star hotels such as Modernhaus SoHo and Arlo SoHo cost ₪800-₪1,500 per night, and apartments such as Radio City Apartments offer better value from ₪800 per night. As for kosher food, New York is paradise: in the Midtown area there are dozens of kosher restaurants, and on 47th Street between 6th and 7th there is a concentration of kosher restaurants. Members of the Lametaylim community recommend the YeahThatsKosher app for finding kosher restaurants. It is also worth getting to know the kosher restaurant area in Brooklyn, in the Williamsburg and Flatbush neighbourhoods.
About New York
New York is the biggest, most diverse and most exciting city in the world. For Israelis it offers a unique experience, with a huge Jewish community and a kosher infrastructure like no other city in the world. The recommended neighbourhoods to stay in are Midtown Manhattan (close to Times Square, Broadway and Central Park), SoHo (a cool atmosphere and boutiques), and the Upper West Side. Brooklyn offers a cool alternative with lower prices. Getting from JFK to Manhattan is possible by AirTrain+subway bus (cheapest) or by shuttle. There are Chabad houses in every borough, hundreds of kosher restaurants and kosher pizzerias in every area.